Virtual Copies not exporting correctly

I swear I had solved this in Backlight 2.

I use virtual copies to create B&W rendition of images sometimes. On republishing my site I am seeing a lot of instances where the B&W version is publishes as the color version (resulting in apparently duplicate images)

Digging through the old forums I find that Publish Setting, File Rernaming can mess with this, but that is off.

If I export the files any other way, I get correct exports.

Anyone have a solution?

I have noticed it is almost certainly a naming issue. virtual copes that are not in the same published album as their parents publish correctly